Skip to main content

Why Long-Form “Canned Coaching” Copy No Longer Works the Way It Used To

Andrea Hill
Published: 10 August 2022

Long-form online coaching copy once built credibility, but now it often signals pressure and inefficiency. See why modern education brands convert better with concise, transparent messaging.

What worked in marketing in the past isn't necessarily what works in the present. Because marketing changes. So we must evolve along with it.

Over the past decade, the online education and coaching industry has gone through several distinct waves of marketing practice. One of the earliest and most influential was the long-form, high-volume copy style that many programs still use today. It was not an accident that this approach became dominant. It grew out of a specific moment in digital commerce, and it served a clear purpose at the time.

In the early years of online coaching, buyers were not yet comfortable purchasing advice, courses, or community experiences from people they knew only digitally. Trust had to be constructed on the page. Long copy served as a surrogate for the relationship building that would normally take place in person. Repeating key ideas created a feeling of familiarity. Layering in story after story gave the impression of depth, substance, and credibility. And the sheer length of the copy played a psychological role. As readers moved through long sections of narrative, they began to feel invested in the time they had spent. That investment made it easier for them to take the next step, whether that step was booking a call or purchasing a course.

That approach shaped an entire generation of online marketing. Many business owners were trained on it, and it became the default pattern for selling digital education. But buyer behavior has shifted, and this style of writing now carries a cost that did not exist when it first emerged.

Today’s buyers are more comfortable with digital transactions, more informed about online marketing techniques, and more equipped to recognize persuasion structures. They are also more time-constrained. Long, looping copy that once conveyed trust now signals something very different for a significant group of customers. Instead of reading it as thorough, they read it as manipulative or inefficient. Instead of interpreting repetition as reinforcement, they interpret it as pressure. Instead of experiencing the content as a relationship-builder, they see it as a tactic designed to wear them down.

In short, yes: this style of content now openly offends or alienates a meaningful segment of buyers. The very people who are most willing to invest in high-quality education tend to be the ones who prefer clarity, brevity, and a direct articulation of value. They reward brands that respect their time. They expect information to be structured, specific, and purposeful. They do not associate length with legitimacy. They associate insight with legitimacy.

Modern marketing for coaching and education businesses is moving toward a different pattern. Instead of equating more words with more trust, it positions trust as the result of sharper thinking and more transparent communication. Instead of repeating the same promises throughout a page, it focuses on distinct proof points that demonstrate capability. Instead of constructing emotional momentum through copy volume, it creates momentum through the usefulness of the content itself.

This does not eliminate the need for story, structure, or personality. Those elements are still essential. It simply means they should serve the reader rather than the sales mechanism. When the content helps people think more clearly about their situation, they infer competence and credibility. When the structure is efficient, they feel respected. And when the narrative is grounded instead of inflated, they feel safe enough to explore further.

For businesses built on intellectual property, expertise, or education, adopting a modern copy approach is not cosmetic. It is strategic. It broadens the audience that is willing to engage, increases trust among the most discerning buyers, and aligns the brand with current expectations rather than past tactics.

The old style of long-form “canned coaching” copy played an important role in its time. But marketing evolves as buyers evolve. What worked in 2010 does not function the same way in 2025, and that creates an opening for brands that are willing to write with more precision, more clarity, and a greater respect for the reader’s intelligence.

Businesses that shift to this modern approach often discover something surprising. They do not need more copy. They need better copy. They need copy that expresses their value with confidence instead of volume. And that shift is what reliably converts today’s buyers without overwhelming them.

If you are rethinking how to present your own educational or coaching offer, the first step is not to add more paragraphs. It is to get clear on what your reader truly needs to understand. When you start there, trust emerges naturally, and the decision to buy feels like the reader’s idea rather than the seller’s intention.

Andrea Hill's
Latest Book

Straight Talk

The No-Nonsense Guide to Strategic AI Adoption

Where other books focus on prompts and tools, this book gives business leaders what they actually need: the frameworks and confidence to lead AI adoption responsibly, without having to become technologists themselves.

Also available at independent booksellers and public libraries.

Are You Ready to Do Better Marketing?

WerxMarketing is all about performance marketing. That means giving you the tools you need to connect with customers, enable your sales efforts, and turn leads into loyal customers. Ready to learn more about how we do that? Book a free consult and bring your questions. See if you like working with us on our dime, and get some good advice in the process.